On May 20, 2026, 11952 Camden Park Drive in Keene's Pointe sold for $1,550,000 after 34 days on the market. Six weeks later, on June 30, 11866 Camden Park Drive sold for $945,000 after 58 days. Both homes are on the same street, both were built in 2006, and both have five bedrooms, four baths and 3,337 square feet of living area. The prices differed by $605,000.
That pair is the outlier in this gated community, which is otherwise one of the more predictable markets on Windermere's side of the Butler Chain. In the sales the West Orange Times & Observer reported from late April through the first week of November 2026, most Keene's Pointe homes sold at close to the same price per square foot, whatever their size. Lake Tibet frontage priced on a separate scale. And the homes that took longest to sell were the smaller ones, not the estates.
Most of Keene's Pointe sold by the square foot
The Observer reported 30 Keene's Pointe sales from April 23 through November 6, 2026. Leave aside four large sales on Grosvenor Shore Drive and Tibet Pointe Circle, covered below, and 26 remain. Twenty-two of those 26 closed between $341 and $516 per square foot. That is our math, dividing each reported price by its reported living area.
The size range inside that band is wide. 11462 Claymont Circle, at 2,314 square feet, sold for $950,000 on September 3, or about $411 per square foot. 6857 Valhalla Way, at 7,153 square feet, sold for $3,300,000 on August 31, or about $461. The home three times larger sold for about $50 more per square foot.
| Address | Sale date, 2026 | Price | Sq ft | Approx. $/sq ft | Days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 11462 Claymont Circle | Sept. 3 | $950,000 | 2,314 | $411 | 10 |
| 8411 Woburn Court | June 29 | $1,100,000 | 2,582 | $426 | 72 |
| 5837 Caymus Loop | June 29 | $1,265,000 | 2,937 | $431 | 38 |
| 6110 Keene's Pointe Drive | Aug. 21 | $1,650,000 | 3,196 | $516 | 126 |
| 6241 Blakeford Drive | Oct. 7 | $1,675,000 | 3,556 | $471 | 41 |
| 5926 Blakeford Drive | June 24 | $2,000,000 | 3,906 | $512 | 40 |
| 6036 Greatwater Drive | July 24 | $1,875,000 | 4,013 | $467 | 55 |
| 6330 Lake Burden View Drive | April 23 | $1,900,000 | 4,460 | $426 | 30 |
| 9222 Tibet Pointe Circle | Aug. 20 | $2,425,000 | 5,323 | $456 | 57 |
| 8402 Lake Burden Circle | May 5 | $2,400,000 | 6,248 | $384 | 155 |
| 6133 S. Hampshire Court | May 8 | $3,000,000 | 6,335 | $474 | 2 |
| 8340 Lake Burden Circle | June 24 | $3,250,000 | 6,848 | $475 | 7 |
| 6857 Valhalla Way | Aug. 31 | $3,300,000 | 7,153 | $461 | 53 |
Four of the 26 sales fell outside the band. 9940 Grosvenor Pointe Circle sold for $3,000,000 on June 29 at 5,071 square feet, about $592 per square foot. The other three were all on Camden Park Drive, and all three fell below it. One was 11866, from the opening, at about $283. 11419 Camden Park Drive, 3,686 square feet, sold for $1,135,000 on June 22, about $308 per square foot. 11333 Camden Park Drive, a 3,449-square-foot home built in 2004, sold for $950,000 on October 1, about $275 per square foot. A fifth Camden Park sale, 11413, closed at $1,395,000 for 3,840 square feet on July 20, about $363 and near the bottom of the band.
A per-square-foot comp gets a buyer or seller close to a fair price on most streets here. The Camden Park sales show where it stops working. The size, room count and build year on a sales record do not separate two homes that sold $605,000 apart. The lot, the condition and the finish do, and a buyer has to price those in person.
Lake Tibet homes priced on a different scale
The four sales left out above are the ones the size math cannot explain. All four were on Tibet Pointe Circle or Grosvenor Shore Drive, from late May through June 2026:
- 9121 Tibet Pointe Circle: $13,200,000 on June 5 for 11,071 square feet, about $1,192 per square foot, after 5 days on the market.
- 9259 Tibet Pointe Circle: $6,050,000 on June 18 for 6,257 square feet, about $967 per square foot, after 293 days.
- 6137 Grosvenor Shore Drive: $7,650,000 on May 28 for 9,571 square feet, about $799 per square foot, after 344 days.
- 6142 Grosvenor Shore Drive: $4,850,000 on June 30 for 6,950 square feet, about $698 per square foot, after 26 days.
The Orange Observer's May 25 to 31 roundup described 6137 Grosvenor Shore Drive as sitting "on the shores of Lake Tibet." Its June 15 to 21 roundup described 9259 Tibet Pointe Circle as having "direct frontage on Lake Tibet." The street name alone is not enough to place a home in this tier. 9222 Tibet Pointe Circle sold in August for $2,425,000, about $456 per square foot, which puts it in the main band with the Valhalla Way and Lake Burden Circle homes.
9259 Tibet Pointe Circle shows what the lake is worth. GrowthSpotter reported that the home sits on 2.21 acres with a boathouse on Lake Tibet that reaches the Butler Chain of Lakes. The previous owners bought it in 2024 for $3.8 million and spent about a year renovating it top to bottom. GrowthSpotter also reported that the buyer had narrowed the search to two houses, one in Isleworth and this one in Keene's Pointe. The home was built in 2007 and has 6,257 square feet, about the size of the S. Hampshire Court home that sold for $3,000,000. The 2026 sale price was about double that.
The days on market in this tier did not follow a pattern. Two of the four sold in under a month, and the other two waited 293 and 344 days. At this price level, the right home and the right buyer have to come to market at the same time. If you own a lake home, the closest comparable sales may be in Isleworth or elsewhere on the Butler Chain rather than in the Keene's Pointe sales record.
The smaller homes took the longest
Thirteen Keene's Pointe sales closed at $1.3 million or less from late April through early November 2026. Their median days on market was 95. The 12 sales from $1.55 million to $3.3 million that listed days on market had a median of 47. Several of the larger homes went fast. 6133 S. Hampshire Court sold in 2 days, and 8340 Lake Burden Circle sold in 7.
Bowden Way had the slowest run in the community. 8375 Bowden Way sold for $1,300,000 on May 22 after 158 days. 8351 Bowden Way sold for $960,000 on August 21 after 130 days. 8525 Bowden Way sold for $900,000 on November 6 after 168 days. On Claymont Circle, 11536 took 107 days and 11537 took 95. 11333 Camden Park Drive took 370.
Ten of those 13 sub-$1.3 million sales still closed inside the same $341 to $516 per-square-foot band as the larger homes. A buyer who wants a Keene's Pointe home under $1.3 million is shopping the slowest part of the market, and in 2026 that part has moved on the buyer's timeline.
This fall's sales were all under $1.7 million
After the Valhalla Way sale on August 31, the Observer reported four Keene's Pointe sales through November 8, 2026. They were 11462 Claymont Circle at $950,000, 11333 Camden Park Drive at $950,000, 6241 Blakeford Drive at $1,675,000 and 8525 Bowden Way at $900,000. Six of the ten weekly Windermere roundups between August 31 and November 8 had no Keene's Pointe sales at all.
The last of the four large Grosvenor Shore Drive and Tibet Pointe Circle sales closed on June 30. In 2026, all four of those sales closed between May 28 and June 30. If you are planning a lake-tier sale or purchase for 2027, the late-spring and early-summer stretch is when this year's comparable sales closed. If you want a home under $1.3 million, the four fall sales had days on market ranging from 10 to 370, a wide spread for a buyer to work with.
Frequently asked questions
Does a Tibet Pointe Circle address mean a lakefront home? No. 9259 Tibet Pointe Circle has Lake Tibet frontage and sold at about $967 per square foot. 9222 Tibet Pointe Circle sold at about $456, in the same band as most of the community. Check each home's lot individually.
What did the least expensive Keene's Pointe sales go for in 2026? In the Observer's reports from April through early November 2026, the lowest price was $900,000, for 8525 Bowden Way on November 6. Four other sales closed at $960,000 or less: 11866 and 11333 Camden Park Drive, 11462 Claymont Circle and 8351 Bowden Way.
Is price per square foot a reliable way to value a Keene's Pointe home? For most homes off the lake, 2026 sales clustered between about $341 and $516 per square foot, which is a useful starting point. The three Camden Park Drive sales between about $275 and $308 and the lake sales at $698 to $1,192 show the range can be much wider for a particular home.
If you're weighing a home on Bowden Way, a Grosvenor Shore Drive estate or anything in between, the Suzanne and Chad Team will go through the street-level sales with you before you price an offer or a listing. Start with our Windermere neighborhood guide, or ask for a home valuation of a Keene's Pointe home you already own.